AZ54

I don't know if it's the lack of game planning or just preseason vanilla play calling but this new offense so far is traditional Bears stuff. We have far too much talent for it to look that bad. I don't know if that's Williams holding onto the ball too long, which seems most likely, or nobody getting open. Williams talent on broken plays is good but he's supposed to be the one who can play on time. Let's hope as the coaches pull back on the playbook for the start of the season and he gains more reps that starts to show up.

Not a lot of discussion here but quietly Caleb Williams outplayed Joe Burrow in practice yesterday. It’s practice so whatever but there has never been a time where Bears fans said after 3 weeks of practice our rookie QB would be able to look better than a top 5 QB. Even Bengals media were impressed.

Scott Pioli was apparently in the room as the trade discussions were underway and that the Bears backed out due to contract demands. In the end we might have i offered more in the trade who knows. I don’t even remember where I read that so I can’t provide a link.

Ditto on Judon. I don’t want the team tied into a big contract on an old player.

https://www.matchquarters.com/p/matchquarters-db-101-technique-analysis

I haven’t seen enough of Wheeler to decide he’s better. He looked good against 3rd and 4th string. I have seen enough to say this should be a competition among the two. There are two more weeks for coaches to let it play out.

I didn’t mention it earlier but I really appreciate all you do to keep this site up and running.

1 to 2 days off lost posts refers to most recent activity? If there is a choice I’d prefer before the game. Else the day after the game. This game largely defines the 53 man roster so there will lots of chatter afterward.

Even our discussions are largely centered on depth. No questions at starters for CB or LB. RB, WR and TE are settled until you get to 3rd or 4th on the depth chart. QB is settled. It is coming down to the trenches and really Dline is set for starters at this point. Booker looks like a solid 3rd DE which was at the top of the wishlist.

I watched a bit of other games and saw a lot of players trip on the turf. It wasn't just limited to Jones and Swift and it's kinda normal in the middle of camp. Legs are tired. The muffed KO is a bigger concern but the coaches were in the stadium and saw the kick. If the wind was swirling as talked about on TV they know if that ball was moving around, much like it did on Tory Taylors crappy punt. They can make the right assessment there. Other than that, with 1 week of practice at a new position everyone is skipping the fact Jones had 6 carries for 34 yards, and 1 TD, including his tripped run. It's hard to say what is going on with the RB competition. We can go in a lot of different directions but cutting Travis Homer saves $1.9mil and he hasn't offered much as a RB. Roschon is bigger and stronger but I'm also not impressed with his lack of quickness and burst. I was hoping he'd improved that over the offseason. The big question is who can pass protect if we're going to go that route, or with Caleb's quick mind and release do we always leak out the RB? If Roschon can improve at pass pro that might be his way onto the roster. I tend to prefer keeping Herbert because there is a consistency to the running game with him as RB2. Caleb needs that help in a rookie season, not a 4th Rd pick next year. I prefer the options be explored around RB3/4.

Lots of film reviews are in so there are plenty of options. I'll post this one since we have a good baseline on Jenkins' work. One thing that surprised me about Williams at his post game press conference was that he was stating the names of the Bills defensive players and what they were doing on plays. This is just preseason and his first game action but it seems like he sees the field differently from all the other rookie QBs we've had before.

My standouts from this game are Austin Booker and Brendan Bates. Bates had some very good blocks and again showed up well in the passing game. Add in his special teams tackle on a kickoff. Carlson is still ahead of him but he’s not nearly as fluid as a receiver. At this point I prefer to keep Bates as a 4th TE and cut Blasingame.

I feel Caleb and the offense struggled to stay on time. Caleb’s natural talent won the day which is a good thing to have when needed. None of that is surprising for a rookie in his first game action. Overall he looks like belongs on the field.

Wait for the film reviews. His hustle is what really stands out. Dude won’t quit on a play.

Despite all the positive reviews this week it has been Dom Rob getting more first team reps. Robinson responded reportedly with some good play. I’m curious to see how they both look in this next game. If Washington found a way to get more out of Robinson that bodes well for the future of our Dline.

In one practice game Booker has shown more positive traits than Dominique Robinson, who I think gets cut. Booker is still young and needs a couple years to add strength but there's enough on this tape to believe he can contribute as a pass rush specialist. As far as the intent of the inside moves perhaps there is some coaching focus there but my hope is that Dexter provides that, not Booker. He was also getting a bit more attention that I expected on some plays. That is likely just the design of the play rather than them scheming against him but it was good to see how he handled those situations and it gives him tape on what to improve. The one thing I didn't see is him really bending around the edge. He's got to add that to his portfolio and I think he can. It'll be good to watch him across the preseason.

Not much worth talking about from that game. My overall impression is that considering we were mainly watching 3rd string players the coaches had them ready to play. Usually these games are sloppy with lots of obvious blown assignments, false starts, etc. Now that's much easier on the defensive side same scheme and all but the offense held their own with a new system and coaches. Which kinda makes me optimistic for the regular season opener. Players... nobody stood out to me except TE Bates. Of course assignment matteres but in these games of backups vs. backups in wk 1 preseason I'm mostly looking for athletes who stand out. Bates is a big dude who can run fluidly in the open field. TE is the notoriously one of the most difficult positions to learn so it's no surprise to see guys like Carlson ahead of him. Will that last over the next few games? Regardless, I won't expect much from him this year and he'd be TE4 so he can only make the 53 via special teams and maybe at the expense of Blasingame. Dline doesn't have any notable depth. Pickens for his former 5 star recruit talent hype should have stood out IF he's going to make a significant contribution this year. As it is now it appears he's just a guy holding a roster spot. Booker looked ok athletically like he belongs but also showed he has much to learn. I'm not impressed by Collin Johnson. He can't run by anybody and he's very stiff getting off the line. If all he can get is contested catches against 3rd/4th stringers that won't get any better against 1st/2nd string. Rypien showed why he's career backup as he's a line of sight thrower. He can't really layer the ball in over coverage. It's all good to the big WR over the top. Or to wide open crossers with nobody underneath. Didn't see enough from Bagent to compare.

I won't dispute what you saw. The video I saw was Poles and Ian going over it back and forth as picks were being made, plus Poles consulting with some of the scouts who are assigned opposition research for their assessment of who the teams ahead of us would draft. In the end they all celebrated and I saw Warren say "it was just like we told you" or something like that. Regardless of his statement I just can't believe Warren is doing opposition research for the draft.

I think that assessment is correct. Poles wanted to hedge his bet to make sure Williams had good WRs. Justin’s failure was not on him per se but if Williams fails so will he. Allen for a 4th was good value in that context even for a one year rental.

that was Ian Cunningham

Glennon wasn’t the mistake. Trubisky was. Every GM has to field a full team every season and sometimes that forces bad short term decisions. Or perhaps we should say difficult decisions. You can add Lucas Patrick to that list so Poles isn’t immune.

Love the long term prospect of the deal but it's also a huge injury gamble. DJ gets the huge guaranteed money locked in really early and Poles gets a bargain relative the future market. It'd be hard to find a better player to put that bet on.

One truth doesn’t infer the other. My take on it is that fixing the center position with the best option for Caleb is job one. If bates wins it outright it’s his and Shelton backs up. If Shelton wins then we’ve got a proven alternative at RG and we can open up that competition. If it’s a wash between Bates and Shelton then we go into figuring who our top 5 are which again could mean competition at RG. Fans are in a rush for answers but reality is we got an extra week of practice we should use that to our best advantage.