AZ54

Yes sometimes people confuse the analogy of comparing similar situations (HC failed at point A succeeded at point as being a comparison of the people themselves. Some people do learn from their mistakes some do not. I think Singletary is one of those who does learn. I'm not pulling for him to be our DC either, nor am I against it if that's what Trestman thinks is the right thing to do. I just think we'll be seeing a lot more from Singletary at some point in the future.

That tells me he's also a good salesman who studies his target, knows what he likes, and then delivers it in the way he'll be successful. He knew Emery loved detail and he went out of his way to provide it. I think the interview with Dennison was the complete opposite. Anyway, this fits what we've heard and read about Trestman: He studies his opponent and learns where his players can exploit them. Let's hope it carries onto the field.

Really? http://www.sfgate.com/sports/article/Singl...win-3178967.php "The biggest thing is those guys in there (the locker room) are excited to play," Singletary said. "I love these guys. They know that. They know what the prerequisites are: work. We have a lot of work to do." When he heard the news in the locker room after the game, quarterback Shaun Hill said, "Everybody started cheering and clapping. People were genuinely happy for him." Singletary was 5-4 in his nine games as interim head coach after taking over the job from the fired Mike Nolan on Oct. 20. More important, he inspired the 49ers to win five of their last seven games to finish the season 7-9 - an overall disappointment but substantially better than the team's 2-7 record as of Nov. 10. "It's a blessing," linebacker Patrick Willis said of his former position coach's promotion. "It's not just because he was a linebacker or because he coached me. I think they've got the right man for the job. He deserved it. He earned it." Read more: http://www.sfgate.com/sports/article/Singl...p#ixzz2IIU1LnQ0 Everyone is so focused on his failure as a HC they forget his success as a head coach. Singletary's biggest problem is that he was a head coach well before he was ready and that stigma will stay with him for some time. Some day he'll get beyond that and I believe he'll be successful as a HC. Not saying that day is today but he might be ready to lead a defense.

Matt Scott is an interesting prospect. After watching him all year I'd say he has good talent overall but his arm strength is average and his ability to read defenses and anticipate is below average. He is very mobile but not elite in this category either. He only played one season due to injuries and due to sitting behind a guy named Nick Foles who ended up starting in Philly this year. Knowing he's only had one full year of playing time he could develop into a decent backup, his ceiling is probably an average starter.

That's a joke right? You have seen what Whisenhunt and Grimm have done here in AZ in the last few years?

Breaking news for Corey Graham: Coaches want to win too. Graham had his chance at CB here in Chicago and he was always trailing his WR so far off that it was an easy pass and catch. Two picks of Manning in the playoffs reminds me of that Cowboys CB who had 3 INT in the Superbowl against Pittsburgh. He got a huge contract from the Raiders and we never heard from him again. I wish him the best.

Add in a very good offensive coordinator to that list. I don't remember any of those Olinemen except for Robbins and only then because he lost his mind, so they weren't exactly household names as a dominant Oline.

IIRC, he became interim HC at the end of a season when the head coach was fired. The team response well and won some games and was more competitive. From there he was given the job. Initially they were more competitive but his Ditkaesque approach soon wore thin and players quit responding. His offense was also boring and predictable. Where have we seen that before? I have no idea how he'd be as a DC and I'm neutral on him as a candidate for that role. One thing is for sure, Trestman needs a guy who can be successful handling complete control of the defense. If not Marinelli, who else is out there?

He runs plays every 12 seconds. A 3-and-out means his defense will get about 1min of rest plus the time it takes to punt. Of course the NFL will come to his rescue often with all the timeouts they force on change of possession so make it 3min. I'm very curious to see how well this works but there are run and gun precedents.

Emery brought in a few WRs of this type last year. I'm not really interested in him as I prefer we add some speed to our stable of bigger WRs. For me Joe Anderson fills this role and he played well on special teams when he got his shot. Don't know how Anderson will fare on the field as a WR. How quickly things change when for years I was hoping we'd add some size to the WR corps. If he runs well and can catch then a very late round pick might worth it but still prefer to find a replacement for Knox's speed.

I do not think Kelly will succeed if he's going to keep his system. His system works great when he has the best athletes on the field. When his athletes are on par with his opponent's defense it doesn't work so well. In the NFL we all know that those things balance out. He never had a really good defense not his expertise of course or emphasis, and for that matter neither did teams in the Pac10/12 thus his offense's numbers tended to be inflated. Running QBs tend not to make it deep into the NFL playoffs-- see: Michael Vick, RGIII, Bobby Douglas. Had to slip that last one in to see if anyone is awake.

Arizona has serious issues with their offense and a very good defense and DC. Why would they want to hire Lovie? The fact they are ignoring him tells me they are now smarter than a box of rocks.

To add to the professionally run team keep in mind Emery greatly expanded our scouting department over the course of the season and added his system of grading to the mix. We don't really know what to expect this draft so it will be interesting but I'm very hopeful.

CFL: 3 downs to go 10yds, Dline must line up 1yd off the LOS. NFL: 4 downs to go 10yds, Dline 11 inches from the Oline. Dline in your face much quicker = get rid of ball quicker but you can take shorter gains since you have 3 downs. Maybe I'm wrong but I wouldn't go to the CFL tapes to see what Trestman will be doing in the NFL. He clearly adapted to the CFL rules and found success quickly there. That in itself is pretty amazing since his roots were in the NFL game for many years. His NFL experience and play calling is what I'm most interested in and he had a lot of success here even if it was a decade ago. Seems to me he understands the concepts that are needed to be successful under any given set of rules.

I said earlier if there is one thing older Bears fans know about Singletary it is that he is studious and willing to accept criticism and work hard to improve himself. I can't believe he hasn't learned some things and improved since his days back in SF. When it was reported that he'd interview for HC I also felt at that time he was interviewing for a potential DC role. Not shocked at all by this rumor.

I expect that Marinelli would first want to sit down and talk with Trestman before making any decision. I assume that happened today. I can't imagine Trestman will wait more than 24hrs for his decision as there are so many recent hires for HC in the league that getting his DC in now is a priority.

You are going to be looking for that person for a very long time and you have no quotes on this board for anyone promoting that. What you described as the Lovie-2 is exactly what Lovie ran when he made himself DC and it was horrible. Marinelli clearly has changed things to be more aggressive but he is not Rex Ryan. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Other thoughts... We did run quite a few stunts last season so I'm not sure why there is so much complaining that we don't do that. Melton is young, had a back injury the second half of the season and still made the Pro Bowl and still some don't like him. Surprising. Without him we had no interior pass rush. We better sign him as he is the first sign of life our interior Dline has had since Harris' Pro Bowl days. Marinelli ran a horrible prevent defense against the Seahawks and ruined my first trip back to Chicago in 5 years. Or was that Lovie's decision? For Lovie's entire tenure Lovie has put our D back on their heels late in games when we had the lead when all we had to do was just keep playing the same solid D we had played all game. Bottom line is we don't know what Marinelli would do unchecked by Lovie. We also don't know who our new HC would bring in as his coordinator so speculating that he, or in this case with no names as candidates, anyone, will be better than what Marinelli has done is pure conjecture. Marinelli gave us a top 10 defense. So the challenge for the new guy is pretty steep. This is especially true because we now are 100% certain we are hiring an Offensive-minded HC. Kinda like hoping Lovie will fix the offense because he can't bring in anyone worse than Terry Shea. I'm not saying a new DC wouldn't do a better job than Marinelli but those who view that as a sure thing, or that any change has to be better than what we have, are wrong IMO. Read the article on Trestman's last couple seasons in Montreal to see his difficulties with the defense.

Given that the defensive personnel will be nearly identical next season how will a significant change in DC and scheme improve the D? I see our best chance at winning in the playoffs as keeping or slightly improving our D while dramatically improving our offense. I can't see where a significant change in scheme, something players like Tillman, Briggs, Urlacher (if he's back), Jennings, Roach, Conte, Wright, Melton, Wootton, SMC, and Paea have never run will make the defense better next year. If we're talking about long term then yes. I look at our offense with a good QB, Pro Bowl WR, Pro Bowl RB and tend to think a few good moves (Oline) and better scheme/coaching can change things for the better now. While our defense might not be dominate they are good. IMO that is our best near term combination to win in the next year or two.

Davis is a horrible route runner and that won't be changing any time soon, if ever. He just has no instincts for the passing game regardless of his ability to catch the ball, which is marginal.

We only had to listen to Emery's press conference after firing Lovie to understand the details he went through to analyze Lovie's performance. This wasn't a simple ...he didn't make the playoffs deal. In just one example, he evaluated Oline performance and compared that to other successful teams. As he said, (paraphrasing) every team has shortcomings on their roster but some know how to overcome them. We didn't. All that data and analysis leads right into the job interviews where he no doubt got more analysis free of charge.

Stoned people may not be out there picking fights but as far as what I've seen in my life they are still doing stupid things. Having seen a couple friends get addicted to marijuana and what it did to their motivation to work and many of the bad decisions they made because "they knew the meaning of life" it's not something I want in a 1st rd pick. Recreational use IMO would be no different than recreational alcohol use but would people say the say thing about a college player who had alcohol abuse issues...draft him anyway? I doubt it. James Brown had addiction issues with marijuana and it affected his work ethic. Vontaze Burfict had issues and it affected his work ethic (just going by his words). I'm not against legalizing marijuana and as more governments go broke more will legalize it so they can tax it. It won't be long before it's a national debate. Not sure where all this data is about alcohol being 10x worse than marijuana. It's already been proven that 1 or 2 beers a day, or a glass of red wine each day, has significant health benefits. In some ways not much different than the fact marijuana has known medical benefits. I agree with BT's point that you have an elite athlete knowingly doing illegal activities. How smart is that knowing they could lose millions of dollars? It says they don't use good judgment in their daily decisions, especially if they've been caught twice or more, and that must be weighed in the decision to draft that guy and hand him millions and risk the future of your franchise on them. Our personal beliefs don't change the rules and laws the players must abide by so we can't ignore how that could impact the team.

There isn't much new in that article regarding Trestman's personality or style as I think that was rumored to be the case last week but it does offer more clarity in terms of his HC focus. It seems to me that after Trestman's interview is when the rumors of Marinelli staying started. I'd have to go back and check the timing to be sure. If that's correct then it fits what that article states: Trestman doesn't know defense and doesn't want to deal with the defense. Why not hand him a proven DC who already has his players and system in place and playing well. I can't believe there are no rumors as to who is coming back for a second interview. If Emery wants to close a deal by Fri then he had to make contact with the second level candidates today.

Just as I was watching and wondering if he was big enough and strong enough to play inside for us he stopped Lacy cold at the goal line. Can't argue the athletic ability at all.

I'd say Hoke, who helped develop Jennings into a Pro Bowl CB and improved the play of a couple young safeties, will get some quick attention around the league. Tice will too, probably not as an OC but as Oline coach absolutely. Bears failures here will be chalked up to lack of talent. Marinelli will be hired too, and quickly if he wants to keep coaching. Mike Phair Dline coach. Helped develop Melton into Pro Bowl player, Wooton turned in his best season, and even SMC turned in an adequate year, his first at a new position. He has to get out from under the Marinelli shadow though but I expect he'd draw some interest around the league.

Kaepernick folds under pressure but we haven't seen much of it because his Oline is so good. Go back and watch some highlights of their last game against Seattle for evidence. Can he get better in this regard? Of course, but the book isn't written on him just yet.