Stinger226

He may wait until the end of the year but the next 3 games will decide what he does. I think we agree. Just dont think he's firing him, if he does, till the end of the yr. Now if he has 5 game losing streak ( 2 already), he may have too. I think Herbert fumbled the ball his first carry with the Bengals.

Just seen a Adam Rank post that said NFL insiders told him, he was keeping Flus no matter what happens this yr. I find when people say they support a coach it is a kiss of death. I think, winning record, he stays, losing record he leaves.

I have just read , not verified , that he originally signed a 5 yr deal when everyone was thinking 4 yr deal. Next yr is playoff time on Poles schedule and if Flus isnt winning, they aint worring about a couple million when they probably have the right QB. Like you said speculation on almost everything, 3 more games will define this yr.

Everyone can be traded, but you dont get rid of your best Offensive player because of one play. He is frustraded like everyone else. CWs miss rate to him is 39.4%, worse in the league. He is one of the highest character players on the team. We will never be a winning team if you keep getting rid of good players. He was great last yr and a history of above average stats with crappy QBs. our biggest problem is a rookie QB playing bad. We looked good when we ran the ball well and CW played confortable. The OL has a big effect on everything right now with major injuries. Play calling comes into play but it will never look good if players dont exicute.

They talked today about signed thru 2025, but Im not sure. Poles aint going to worry about 1 yr left,r it comes down to having a winning record and developiong CW. If he doesnt win, he will be gone. Not the right question at this time with a potenial 5-4 record. Its the division strerch that will sink him.

Clearly the offense is out of sycn, Its a combination of play calling, coaching decisions, injuries are starting to jack the Ol, and CW is headed in the wrong direction. I seen where he leads the league in miss rate with WRs. 39.4 %, it just might be to DJ Moore, that's who they were talking about and they said it was one of the worse in the league. If CW plays better, the play calling looks better and we actually look like a legitmate offense. We need to run the ball, lots of first downs and CW can make a few big plays. The D now has injuries and we now have to rely on offense.

So do you want to cut him or trade him now? He is our best offensive player.

When you look on his career, those are black marks for sure but its also what did that was good. Ultimately its about winning. Most people said that 9 or 10 victories would be satifactory, with 4 wins and a likely win this week gives us 5 with 8 games left. The last 2 weeks create doubt but that is still possibly. Im one of the idiots thar shot for 12 wins, playoff berth. Do we have a successful season with 9 wins and Caleb playing well at the end of the season?

I am not speaking to here, I dont remember what everyone wanted, Im on X. Lots of people calling for Poles to trade Herbert because we werent using him. Poles trades him and now their complaning because they didnt get enough. He had no valve ,all these dreamers that thought someone was given us a 4th or 5th round pick was unrealistic. I think it comes down to some people just complain and are never satisfied. I wanted to keep him for a depth piece, more value for a team trying to win.

Everyone has a right to be critized and we can guess on what the play call is, whether Caleb changed it. whether Kmet is the first read, 2nd, or 3rd. I would say he probably isnt the first read on all of those plays . Now also is the DCs taking away the middle of the field because CW struggles on outside plays a lot. OCs usually do game plans attacking defenses. Washington and Arizona both have lousy CBs. So did he develop the game plan to attack the outside? Execution is bad so hard to say who we blame for what.

We actually dont know that, it could be CW looking for a big play. Is he envolved enough in the offense, absolutely not.

I agree with that, players need to be accountable too. Its not all his fault but he is involved.

Anyone can say what they want but realistically can we fix this? First a win this week could help a lot. Second injured players coming back wouldnt hurt. ( no control over that)/ Thrid, Flus aint leaving and I now think he should, how about Waldron? We have 2 options in the room Kerry Joseph and Tom Brown. Tom Brown has called plays in Carolina and was assitant HC with the Rams before that. I would say promote Tomas Brown to OC. 4th simplifly it for CW , he is talented but does he have too much on his plate for a rookie? According to his play, that would be a yes. 5th Flus turn over DC play calling to Williams and concentrate on being a HC. I think the biggest effect on this team would be to get injured players back. What say you

I agree, the hangover from the Washington game has instilled a lack of cofidence and doubt. The savage media keeps up the chaos from that game. We have a snowball that is turning into an avalanche. How do we correct it?

I wanted to make the playoffs this year and am disappointed. Was that asking too much in 2 and 1/2 yrs in a complete rebuild with a rookie QB? We probably have 3 top 50 picks, so reinforcements are coming but not now.

If you watch the replays, Kmet is open many times and isnt getting the ball thrown to him. I get progression on routes but good QBs throw to open players and not into coverage. That's not on coaches. CW is making bad decisions, many times when rushed he didnt dump off to the outlet and held the ball to long. That is not by design. He is a rookie and deserves patience but everything is not always the coaches fault. Players need to be accountable too. Now we have injuries that effect everything offense. Wright is hurt, Jenkins is always hurt , Nate Davis is useless, we are down to 3rd string at LT. Billings, Sweat, Brisker, Gordon on defense eventually matters. We have a chance at home to go 5-4 but that is not a given. If we got bodies back can we go 4-4 the rest of the season? Unless CW actually starts playing well, I would say no.

I was mad yesterday and bad mouthed everyone but the truth is our phenom QB is missing WRs, not throwing to open WRs, and holding the ball to long. Giving CW the whole playbook and letting him change plays was a bad idea. They should have did what they did in Washington, keep it simple. Moved the pocket with a beatup OL but instead they are developing the QB instead of worrying about winning . Watch replays of the game. Forcing development isnt working. That's what everyone wanted .

We played bad that is on coaches and players. Listen to Olin Kreutz speak the truth on the SCORE on Audacy. At some point injuries come into play, 2 starters gone in the secondary, no Sweat(huge), Billings went out early. The OL affects everything on the offense. It is clear the blow up from the Washington game has lingered into this week. Flus has lost the team, he needs to be gone but as some suggested, CW development would not be benefited by throwing in a new coach. We just may be stuck with this until next year. We have to remember the most important need this year is to develop CW. Hopefully we picked the right QB. I have doubts now. We had the same talk last yr with Fields having a new play caller. Sometimes its the player.

Im just pissed off right now, but he isnt playing well and that's not all on the coaching.

Actually I am not being sarcastic. Im tired of this crap. I want all new. It takes me longer than you guys to get negative but I am now and its not pretty. We need to make everyone accountable , coaches coach(bad) and players play, we cant just blame this on coaches. Maybe tommorrow, I will think the other coaches can save CW but anyone saying he's playing well right now is lying to themselves.

What I wanted to see is with the ClusterF last week, did it bring us closer together or they would quit on him. He needs to go , stated what I wanted in the game thread. Hoke/ HC Williams/DC Tom Brown/OC. Time to think about if we drafted the right QB, seems not to be the case to me. 2 bad games, missing WRs and holding the ball to long. Lets just have a fresh start next year, with new coaches and a new QB.

I think the tean has given up on Flus, lackluster defense, another bad game by CW. I seen a commentator say that that Hail Mary can bring a team together or tear it apart. Guess what happened? Im all; in on letting him go now. Get rid of Waldron too. Tom Brown the QB coach has called plays in the NFL before. Make Williams the DC and have Jon Hoke be the new head coach. Also time to hold players accountable. CW has been bad in the last 2 games except for 8 minutes. He misses WRs and holds the ball to long. They say having a new coach going into his second year is tough on a young QB. Trade CW get some 1st round picks and have a new QB, new coach, new OC and start fresh next year with everyone on the same page. What say you?

Andy Reid was passed up? Never heard that story before. Can I say if we win today we will have a 71% of being a wildcard. I think it was a ESPN guy said that. Not sure he looked at last 7 games.

Yes never heard the rest of the story, WED and came back on the field. The bigger news is Sweat not playing, Brisker and Gordon out. The key to the game is CW actually having a complete game. If he plays like last week, late game hero wont always work. All that has been said this week it comes back to CW having a good game.